Is Relational Investors' Ralph Whitworth Worth His Big Paycheck?
Ralph Whitworth of San Diego’s Relational Investors LLC is back in the news because he thinks Occidental Petroleum’s chief executive makes too much money.
Whitworth is teaming up with CalSTRS, the massive California State Teachers Retirement System, to boot out board members who approved paying CEO Ray Irani $857 million over the past 10 years.
Executive pay is an important issue. Irani sure does make a lot of money; but then again, he has made a lot of money for shareholders.
No one seems to be asking a fundamental question: Who is Ralph V. Whitworth. What qualifies him as an expert on excessive pay? How much does he make? What socially useful service does he perform? How does his business compare with the executives he criticizes?
Unlike publicly-traded Occidental Petroleum, Relational Investors is a private limited liability company organized in Delaware. It isn’t required to disclose salaries.
Judging by his assets and his lavish lifestyle, there’s an irony in Whitworth complaining about excessive pay: It’s the proverbial pot calling the kettle black.
Outside of the boardroom, Whitworth is perhaps best known for paying Paul McCartney $1 million to play at a 50th birthday bash in Rancho Santa Fe for his wife, Wendy, Larry King’s CNN producer.
Wendy filed for divorce less than a year later. In divorce papers, she described her and Ralph’s exceptional lifestyle:
“For the last four years of our marriage, we have enjoyed a very lavish lifestyle, including multiple luxurious residences, traveling exclusively on private planes, taking luxurious vacations, buying designer clothing, and essentially partaking of, and enjoying, the best of everything that life has to offer. We have had the good fortune of not having to consider the cost of goods and/or services as money has truly been no object in our daily lives.”
The Federal Aviation Administration’s database shows Relational Investors LLC has registered a pair of Falcon 2000 business jets. One of them flew Thursday from San Francisco to Sacramento, and recently flew from San Diego to Montana and back in a day, according to the flight tracking service, FlightAware.
San Diego County real estate records show Whitworth has indeed been keeping up with his superrich neighbors. His two homes in the San Diego area — one in posh Rancho Santa Fe and another along the La Jolla coast — have a combined assessed value of more than $16 million.
Then there’s Whitworth’s massive collection of dragsters, hot rods and funny cars. He had planned to open an automotive museum in his home state of Nevada, but changed his mind and auctioned some of them off for nearly $7 million last year. See if you can guess which one of the cars below sold for $550,000:
Finally, whatever Whitworth’s salary is, you can bet he pays a lower tax rate than Irani and most Americans do. Relational Investors, unlike Occidental Petroleum, is a partnership. Under a tax loophole, a managing partner like Whitworth is taxed at low 15% capital gains rates. Whitworth’s eight-figure income is considered a return on investment, not compensation for services, even though it is CalPERS and CalSTRS who have put up most of the money for Relational Investors.
Whitworth’s wealth derives from the $6 billion he manages for pensions in California, North Carolina and Alaska, among others — or more precisely the 20% “incentive fees” he is paid for beating the S&P 500, which he has done with some consistency, to his credit.
Relational’s strategy is to buy up a large position of underperforming companies and then force changes with the goal of unlocking unrealized value. In 2006, Relational locked horns with The Home Depot, leading the home improvement chain to dump its chief executive, who left with a $210 million “severance” package.
Relational Investors is headed by Whitworth and David Batchelder, who met while working in the 1980s for Texas oilman and corporate raider T. Boone Pickens.
CalPERS became Relational’s first big investor in March 1996 and remains its biggest backer today, with about $1.5 billion invested. Relational’s “activist” investing strategy has yielded annual returns of 10.77%, according to a March 31, 2001 study conducted by Wilshire Consulting on behalf of CalPERS. That means $100 invested in Relational in 1996 would be worth $415.02 today.
(By comparison, you could have doubled your money investing the same $100 in Occidental Petroleum over the past decade decade later).
Relational charges a 1.5 percent fee and receives an incentive fee of 20 percent for beating the S&P 500 Index.
The biggest problem with Relational, however, isn’t Whitworth’s personal spending or his fund’s fees or performance, but a deeper, more troubling conflict-of-interest:
Whitworth warns public corporations to avoid even the appearance of conflicts, but his investment firm doesn’t practice what it preaches.
Officials from CalPERS and other funds that invested in Relational wound up with jobs, consulting contracts and corporate directorships, courtesy of the San Diego fund. These ties give the appearance that Relational Investors offers rich rewards for those who help it secure investments.
Relational’s origins came under scrutiny earlier this year when documents posted by CalPERS revealed Relational paid nearly $17 million to a little-known New York firm called Tullig Inc. (formerly Donal J. Murphy Associates) to help secure an investment from CalPERS. The pension fund launched an investigation.
A review of public documents and interviews shows that Tullig Inc. isn’t the only one who has profited from Relational.
The San Diego money management firm has put several pension officials on its payroll and on corporate boards under sometimes questionable circumstances:
- Former treasurer of North Carolina Richard Moore steered $500 million in state retirement funds to Relational Investors in August 2008 and then joined the San Diego firm in April 2009 as a managing director. Whitworth has said that Moore’s hiring was unrelated to the pension’s investment. North Carolina paid Relational $6.6 million in fees last year under a generous fee agreement.
- In 2004, Relational hired James Hearty, the former executive director of the Massachusetts pension system who left after a high-profile battle with Treasurer Timothy Cahill. At the time, the $32 billion Massachusetts Pension Reserves Investment Management system (MassPRIM) was considering an investment in Relational. (The deal later fell through.)
- Beverly Benedict Thomas, a Los Angeles-area political consultant who also serves as a placement agent, received a fee of nearly $1 million for helping Relational land a $300 million investment in 2008 from CalSTRS, the California teachers’ retirement system. Thomas, a former assistant treasurer under California Treasurer Kathleen Brown served as a member of the board of CalPERS and CalSTRS from 1993 to 1995, according to regulatory filings with the SEC.
- Relational has also doled out board seats to former CalPERS officials. The firm tapped Thomas and Richard H. Koppes, former CalPERS general counsel, for board seats on Apria Healthcare Group. and installed Sheryl Pressler, another former CalPERS official, on the board of Nuevo Energy, another company in which Relational had a big stake.
None of these moves was illegal, but Relational’s questionable relations have been largely ignored here in California.
They deserve careful scrutiny. The pension world has been rocked by a “pay for play” bribery and kickback scandal that started in New York and prompted reforms at CalPERS, which has issued new rules and hired a law firm to review the activities of placement agents.
Change is coming to the pension world, but it doesn’t seem that Relational has gotten the message.
Winnemucca dentist, Dan Debonis helped Ralph attend UNR, then on to law school at Georgetown.
While in Washington he worked on the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee staff of Senator Paul Laxalt and on the 1984 Reagan election campaign.
When he left Washington he went to work for T. Boone Pickens and learned from the master about finance and managing investments.
In the years since leaving Pickens Ralph’s business enterprises have flourished. He is a partner in Relational Investors, a $3 billion investment fund with large holdings in major corporations.
He is a Director of some of America’s largest corporations.
BTW, Mitt Romney still receives a generous salary from Bain Capital taxed at the low 15% capital gains rate, and Romney’s wealth is hidden in blind trusts.
I don’t think its a matter of how big the salary is, I thinks it’s a matter of wealthy people should pay taxes at the same rate that normal citizens do.
I met Ralph at a Barret Jackson Auction ~5 years ago. I fully respect him for the casual person that he was. He didn’t know me but still had an hour just to carry on a conversation about everything but himself. Some days people just get too hung up on what other people have done for themselves and forget what many of the weathy people have done for man-kind. As for how much Tax one individual should pay….If you were Ralph and you paid $15 million per year in taxes…IS THAT NOT ENOUGH for one individual. Give him credit for the good he does…Don’t brandish him for what he doesn’t do. Keep your head high Ralph…you’re a just a good person that has done well for himself.
Ian from Canada
The REAL VICTIMS of these obscene money managers are THE People who are: denied insurance when they are injured at work – a favorite of Cal. Workers Comp, if you don’t just give up when you are DENIED work comp, the well funded District Attorney will gleefully PROSECUTE YOU FOR INSURANCE FRAUD!!!! The SCAM is PURE GERALD PARSKY. and is BRIBERY PER SER as well as Malicious prosecution. The Insurance Companies have highly paid Liars – I mean investigators who make up crazy lies and take them to the D.A.’s HIGHLY Bribed – woops I mean Funded – INSURANCE FRAUD Division. Of course, the Public defenders do not have time to sort through the paper work, so IT’s PLEA BARGAIN OR REPRESENT yourself.
Parsky has INFECTED – woops – guided their agendas and investments – the once honorable NON PROFIT Industry. Which began as ways for the wealthy to support those less fortunate. HA HA!!!! Humane Society of United States (HSUS) who are guided and managed by Parsky are parasitis leeches who prey on the suffering of animals. falsely stating that they help animals. WRONG!!!! All of these non profits (ALF, PETA, ASPCA) use their FREE MONEY to PAy themselves FIRST. Then HSUS for example has 65 full time attorney who are very busy filing lawsuits all over this country (60 or so currently) HSUS is using the tried and true PARSKY PLAN of BRIBERY for Prosecutors to FILE ANIMAL CRUELTY against anyone whom they have a vendetta against. Providing that person owns an animal. It is INSANE. Thier deceptive advertising and practices are demonic to say the least. The Parsky Plan is based in part on PASSING local Laws, Statutes and Ordinances to literally VIOLATE The US and State Constitutions. Parsky’s BUDDY, Riverside Ca. Board of Supervisor, Jeff Stone – AKA Hillbilly mafia is trying to SECEDE 13 Counties from the State Of California. They are de facto IN BED with Scientology, The Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood on top of Blatant Corruption of the County Of Riverside’s supposed Agencies. from The Distric Attorney – Jeff Stones son Jason – a recent law school grad is Prosecuting INNOCENT VICTIMS of HSUS – which took over Riverside Animal Control, using PURE NAZI ideals with the MAFIA racketeering techniques.