Category: Uncategorized
Wall Street Follies
Lloyd Blankfein writing in the FT on the lessons of the crisis:
The first is that risk management should not be entirely predicated on historical data. In the past several months, we have heard the phrase “multiple standard deviation events” more than a few times. If events that were calculated to occur once in 20 years in fact occurred much more regularly, it does not take a mathematician to figure out that risk management assumptions did not reflect the distribution of the actual outcomes. Our industry must do more to enhance and improve scenario analysis and stress testing.
Absolutely right. Ever since we went off the gold standard, financial crises occur once a decade. But Wall Street’s risk models, despite all their complexity, appear to be blind to this simple fact. As Blankfein says, it doesn’t take a mathematician to understand that. It takes common sense.
Andrew Lahde, a young hedge fund manager, had a great deal of common sense. He made one of the most successful hedge fund bets of all time in 2007, delivering a near 870% return by shorting subprime.
He famously walked away last year after writing this scathing letter in which he advocates hemp and blasts the “idiots whose parents paid for prep school, Yale, and then the Harvard MBA.” The kind of people, in other words, who work for Lloyd Blankfein.
Before he left, Lahde wrote in 2008 that he was shorting commercial real estate even though prices remained high. As he explained in this letter to shareholders, Lahde realized that the commercial real estate market was doomed even as the risk models were telling everyone else to stay the course.
The losses will materialize. Admittedly I don’t have a clue how severe the losses will be. I don’t have a model that can correctly predict all the variables. Luckily no one else on the planet has such a model either. I gave up on the ability of models to correctly predict the value of securitizations a few years ago. I do know one thing though. It is safe to assume a market is dead when deal volume falls to zero, as was the case with CMBS issuance during January 2008. (emphasis added)
Blankfein at least has the good sense to admit he misjudged it all. After ticking off the numerous failures of risk management by Goldman Sachs and others, Blankfein argues against a regulation of risk that protects us from the 100-year storm. “Taking risk completely out of the system,” he says, “will be at the cost of economic growth.
Is he serious? We are entering a deflationary spiral today because of a failure of risk management that is simply breathtaking. And this is at least the second “100-year storm” to hit the United States in the past 100 years.
If Wall Street can’t design a financial system that can weather such storms, the government must.
Larry Summers and D.E. Shaw
From Asia Times’ Inner Workings:
White House economic advisor Larry Summers, a former Treasury Secretary and President of Harvard University, had brief career at one of the world’s biggest hedge funds, D.E. Shaw & Co.
According to sources who attended meetings with him, Summers traveled to Asia during July 2007 with a pitchbook recommending the AAA-rated tranches of collateralized debt obligations to Asian sovereign funds and financial institutions, in his capacity as a Managing Director of the hedge fund D.E. Shaw.
In July 2007 the AAA-rated tranches of mortgage-backed securities backed by subprime collateral were trading at around 90 cents on the dollar. Now they are trading at less than 40 cents on the dollar. They are the “toxic assets” that the US government now is proposing to buy from banks to unclog their balance sheets.
According to my sources, Summers enthusiastically urged Asian investors including sovereign funds to purchase such instruments just weeks after the collapse of a Bear, Stearns hedge fund whose failure triggered the collapse of the whole structured market. I do not know precisely what was in Summers’ pitchbook, but if I were a member of a Congressional committee responsible for the oversight of economic policy, I would very much want to know what was in it.
Shadow Banking
Bill Gross of PIMCO, the world’s biggest bond fund:
“The levered global economy long ago morphed from a banking-dominated regime to one that hid behind securitized lending and structures resembling a ‘shadow banking’ system. SIVs, hedge funds, CDOs and increasingly levered mortgage and investment banks fueled asset appreciation in all investment markets, which in turn propelled real economic growth and employment to unsustainable levels. But, with U.S. housing prices as its trigger, the delevering process did a Wile E. Coyote and headed over the cliff in mid-year 2007, dragging down almost all asset prices except government bonds….
Those who argue strongly for a recapitalization of the banking system, however, may be missing the distinction between the banking system as we once knew it, and the “shadow banking” system that superseded it.”
Public Acceptance of Evolution
From The Economist:

Madoff victims: San Diego edition
For a clickable map, go here.

